vcu

Science religion and faith

« Why Paul Draper can't reasonably believe in God | Main

A Question about Francis Collins's lecture, "The Language of God"

In his book 1776, David McCollough repeatedly describes George Washington as a man who sees the world not as he wishes it to be, but as it really is. He makes the point that this was one of Washington's greatest traits as a leader of the army.

After listening to Collins's lecture, and/or reading his book, do you think he is a man who sees the world as it really is, or as he wishes it to be?

- Brian Cassel

Comments

Does Collins see the world as it really is or as he wishes it to be?

Well, he takes a certain perspective.
What more can we say? (What REALLY is...hmmm).

What's lacking in his work(from my perspective) is a really solid integration of his spiritual beliefs and scientific theory. There's a gap there...an unnecessary gap. He, like many other theists, holds strong to the position that there is a god but doesn't really show how scientific theory and research give any real evidence or support for such a claim. He presents old arguments that don't really do anything to integrate science and faith and doesn't really give the serious and sincere thinker/seeker a solid theory/philosophy to consider.

Consider this, for example: In Romans, chapter 1 verse 19 (or 15, I forget) Paul says that we can know that there is a god through the observation of creation. How can this be? How can nature/the relative world/material existence reveal to us that there is a god. How can all the scientific data and research, or anything we observe in creation for that matter, lead us to the understanding that there is a god?

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)




 

Lectures

View archives


Virginia Commonwealth University
Life Sciences and Religion Community Forum of Central Virginia
E-mail: forum@vcu.edu
Updated: 09/06/2006
P.O. Box 842021
312 North Shafer Street
Richmond, Virginia 23284-2021
Phone: (804) 628-1926