One Change France Should Make: A Modest Proposal for the Top 35 Rule
After several years at the helm of NASCAR, Brian France said last Monday that NASCAR will minimize the number of changes it makes this year. His rationale was that NASCAR needed to bring back lost fans. I (and others) couldn’t agree more that the rapid changes he instituted did dampen the enthusiasm of many fans toward the sport they love(d).
However, there should be one change instituted as quickly as possible — the elimination of the “top 35 rule.” Joe Menzer in his NASCAR.com column on Tuesday called for the rule to be eliminated. Jeff Burton has indicated that sponsors for teams outside the top 35 are few and far between since there is no guarantee their teams will make the race. Even Darrell Waltrip was quoted in Menzer's article acknowledging that the “top 35 rule” has drawbacks as well as benefits to the sport.
Last year I wrote that the “top 35 rule” was patently unfair and in effect was creating “franchises."
If we’re not going to eliminate the rule entirely, how’s this for a compromise: top 12 must qualify on time (with so many past champions probably in the top 12, the chances of those drivers not making it are miniscule), positions 13-25 are guaranteed starting spots, and 26-42 (26-43 if no past champion’s provisional is used) qualify on time. That gives teams that have faster times than those in positions 13-25 a much better chance of making the race and not having to pack it in for the weekend at great expense.
Then again, I’m probably “spitting into the wind” on this one!
Jon
Comments
I like reducing the number of guaranteed spots, but why penalize the top 12 drivers? In that setup it would be more beneficial to be 13th-25th than 12th to guarantee you make the race.
Posted by: mike | January 29, 2008 4:25 PM
Mike: Good question! My rationale was that drivers have to be in the top 12 to make the Chase, so simply being 13th and guaranteed a spot means no chance for a championship so those just a few places behind 12th have motivation to reach the top 12 regardless of then having to make a race on time.
Posted by: Jon | January 30, 2008 10:52 AM